Nature-Based Solutions for Coastal and Riverine Flood and Erosion Risk Management
- Vouk, I., Pilechi, V., Provan, M., Murphy, E. (2021). Nature-Based Solutions for Coastal and Riverine Flood and Erosion Risk Management. Canadian Standards Association, Toronto, ON.
Canadian communities and infrastructure are vulnerable to coastal and riverine flood hazards. The risks associated with coastal and river flooding are escalating as a result of development in river floodplains and coastal zones, and the effects of climate change on flood and erosion hazards. There is growing interest in the potential for Nature-based Solutions (NbS) to play a role in managing these risks, owing in part to Canada’s co-leadership of the Nature-based Solutions Action Track of the Global Commission on Adaptation. Despite this increasing interest in NbS for coastal and riverine flood and erosion risk management, they remain relatively underutilized in Canada. Standards and guidelines can contribute to mainstreaming NbS by clarifying the underlying concepts and principles, raising awareness, and educating practitioners, potential project proponents, and the public. This review and synthesis of published literature and interviews with stakeholders and experts was conducted to:
- Assess how NbS can be used to manage flood and erosion risks in coastal and riverine environments in Canada; and
- Determine needs and opportunities for standards to support deployment of NbS to reduce coastal and riverine flooding and erosion risks.
NbS for coastal and riverine flood and erosion risk management are strategies or measures that depend on, or mimic, natural system processes to provide flood and erosion risk management function, while delivering a suite of environmental and other societal co-benefits. NbS embrace the principles of “whole system” analysis, adaptive management, multi-disciplinary teams, innovation, and long-term planning for uncertainty. They can be deployed through sustainable planning and regulatory frameworks that recognize the value of natural assets and infrastructure in supporting risk management objectives (e.g., Integrated Water Resources Management and Integrated Coastal Zone Management), and/or the targeted deployment of nature-based features to provide specific flood and erosion risk management functions. Nature-based features can deliver flood and erosion risk management benefits in a variety of ways, for example:
- In coastal regions – beaches/dunes, reefs, and wetlands provide buffers against wave action, storm surges, and erosion;
- In river watersheds – wetlands, reconnected floodplain areas, and restored river channels enhance groundwater infiltration, reduce or delay runoff, and attenuate peak flood flows and water levels; and
- In estuaries – marsh and wetland systems can be preserved, expanded, or restored to provide additional hydraulic storage and attenuate waves.
NbS span a continuum of human intervention from green (least intervention) to grey (traditional hard infrastructure); from simply conserving or protecting existing natural systems (e.g., floodplain preservation), to enhancing or restoring natural processes (e.g., beach nourishment), to hybrid or grey-green solutions that integrate hard engineering or structural measures with more natural features (e.g., buried revetments), to “greening” traditional infrastructure (e.g., by incorporating features to enhance ecological value or provide habitat).
Although there are Canadian examples of NbS for flood and erosion risk management that date back to the 1970s, they remain relatively underutilized today. Key barriers to broader uptake include challenges in predicting performance of NbS in distinct and varied Canadian regional settings, a paucity of data demonstrating the performance and track record of NbS, a shortage of highly qualified professionals, stakeholder perceptions that NbS are more uncertain or less effective than (hard engineering) alternatives, project funding models that disincentivize NbS, undervaluation of the co-benefits of NbS in conventional economic analyses and financing models, a lack of authoritative technical guidance, and complex governance and regulatory environments.
The growth in research and interest surrounding NbS has led to the proliferation of numerous reports and guidance documents relevant to the implementation of NbS for coastal and riverine flood and erosion risk management. With a few exceptions, the majority of guidance is relatively high-level, and lacks either the technical detail or region-specific contexts needed to support effective design and implementation of NbS for coastal and riverine flood and erosion risk management across Canada. Collectively, however, available and emerging guidance provides a sound foundational basis for working towards implementation of best practices through future Canadian national standards and design guides. The benefits of national standardization and guidance would include mainstreaming of NbS principles, education of stakeholders and potential proponents on factors affecting the performance of NbS, and increased investor confidence in NbS projects. In particular, monitoring and evaluation protocols for NbS, and frameworks supporting evaluation and deployment of NbS represent potential short-term opportunities for standardization to facilitate wider adoption.
Knowledge and research gaps to be addressed to enable the development of Canadian guides and standards for NbS in coastal zones and river watersheds include:
- Evidence of NbS performance across distinct and varied Canadian coastal and river settings, particularly northern environments, where NbS are relatively untested;
- Improvement and validation of predictive tools;
- Potential adverse impacts of NbS; and
- An improved understanding of the comparative performance of non-structural (i.e., planning-based), conventional, and nature-based (including hybrid) flood and erosion risk management solutions in achieving multiple benefits.
- Ivana Vouk, National Research Council Canada
- Vahid Pilechi, National Research Council Canada
- Mitchel Provan, National Research Council Canada
- Enda Murphy, National Research Council Canada
Project Advisory Panel
- Danika van Proosdij, Saint Mary’s University
- James Bornemann, New Brunswick Southeast Regional Service Commission
- Joanna Eyquem, Intact Centre on Climate Adaptation, University of Waterloo
- John Sommerville, Natural Resources Canada
- Laurence Forget-Dionne, Infrastructure Canada
- Michelle Molnar, Municipal Natural Assets Initiative
- Natalia Moudrak, Intact Centre on Climate Adaptation, University of Waterloo
- Ana-Maria Tomlinson, CSA Group
- Hélène Vaillancourt, CSA Group
- Kenneth Clogg-Wright, CSA Group (Project Leader)
This work has been produced by the National Research Council of Canada (NRC) as a service to, and is licenced to, the Canadian Standards Association (CSA). The information contained in this report is for general information purposes only in regards to the subject matter covered. The NRC and CSA make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability or availability with respect to the report or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained in the report for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.
In no event shall the NRC be liable for any claim, or any direct, indirect, special or consequential damages, or any damages whatsoever (including, but not limited to, procurement of substitute goods or services; loss of use, data, or profits; or business interruption) howsoever caused and on any theory of liability, whether in an action of contract, strict liability, or tort (including negligence or otherwise) arising in any way out of or in connection with this report or the use of this report, even if the NRC is advised of the possibility of such damage. You will not make claims of any kind whatsoever upon or against the NRC, either on your own account or on behalf of any third party, arising directly or indirectly out of your use of the e-guide.
2021 Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada, as represented by the National Research Council Canada.